Comparison
Averages vs simulation over time
A spreadsheet multiplies average times by volumes. It cannot show when orders wait for a shared machine or miss their due date. A deterministic discrete-event simulation runs the week with fixed nominal times and shows these effects. The same input always gives the same result, so a difference between two variants comes from the change you made.
In short
A spreadsheet multiplies average times by volumes. It cannot show when orders wait for a shared machine or miss their due date. A deterministic discrete-event simulation runs the week with fixed nominal times and shows these effects. The same input always gives the same result, so a difference between two variants comes from the change you made.
Section
What the model sees
Spreadsheet averages
- Average cycle times and average demand
- One capacity number per station
- No queues, shared machines or order sequence
Deterministic simulation over time
- Fixed nominal times for stations, routings, buffers, transport and shifts
- Queues, shared machines, order sequence and due dates across the week
- The same input always gives the same result
Section
What you can decide
Spreadsheet averages
- Capacity looks sufficient on paper
- The bottleneck is guessed from the highest load
- Hard to tell what a change really gives
Deterministic simulation over time
- The bottleneck with its cause and the periods when it limited the line
- WIP, lead time and on-time delivery for each variant
- A difference between two variants comes from the change
Next step
Have a decision to test?
Describe your layout and the decision you are weighing. A DBR77 expert will show you how to test it on the digital twin, starting from the data you have.
Questions
Have a question about this topic?
Tell us what it is about. We will reply within one business day.